Matty’s Toy Stop is the ultimate destination for all your toy needs! Since 1988, our family-owned and operated business has been dedicated to providing an extraordinary toy shopping experience. What began as a humble presence in flea markets has flourished into three thriving store locations, making us one of the largest independent toy retailers in the country. Serving the vibrant New York area, we are also proud to have established a strong online presence, showcasing our own product line and partnering with esteemed marketplaces like Amazon and Walmart.
At Matty’s Toy Stop, we have carved out a niche by curating an exceptional selection of educational, mainstream, closeouts and specialty toys, along with distinctive baby products. Our commitment to offering a diverse range of products ensures that every customer can find something to ignite their imagination and foster learning. We take immense pride in delivering the highest level of personalized customer service in the industry, going above and beyond to make each shopping experience truly memorable.
Our reputation extends beyond our wide selection and outstanding customer service. Matty’s Toy Stop is renowned for having the hottest and hardest-to-find toys on the market. We have become the go-to destination for collectors, enthusiasts, and families seeking the most sought-after playthings. By consistently staying ahead of the latest trends and sourcing unique items, we have earned the trust and loyalty of our customers, who have become an integral part of the Matty’s family.
Despite our growth and success, we have never lost sight of our roots as a small family-owned business. We take great pride in our ability to offer exceptional quality and service, ensuring that our customers’ needs are always met. As we expand our online shopping community, we remain committed to upholding these principles. Whether you choose to visit one of our store locations or explore our virtual aisles, you can expect nothing less than a delightful experience backed by our unwavering dedication.
Friendly Staff
Our employees can assist you in finding a great gift for any child.
Let’s be for all
Discover why and how our stores are totally new way to shop for toys.
Free Gift Wrapping
Our stores offer free gift wrapping on all in-store purchases.
High Quality Products
All of our products high quality and durable. Kid tested and parent approved!
Happy Customers
Matty’s Toy Stop has been serving the Long Island community since 1988!
Gift Cards
Gift Cards are sold in-store and wrapped!